British and Irish Lions: Andy Irvine keen to move on from James Horwill controversy

Last Updated: 02/07/13 11:22am

  • Share:
James Horwill: Has twice been cleared of stamping and will play in final Test

James Horwill: Has twice been cleared of stamping and will play in final Test

Sky Bet

British and Irish Lions tour manager Andy Irvine says he is eager to move on from the decision to clear James Horwill of stamping.

The Australia captain is free to play in the Test series decider in Sydney after the International Rugby Board's appeal of the initial decision to exonerate him was not upheld.

Horwill had been cited for allegedly stamping on Alun Wyn Jones during the first Test but was cleared after an initial hearing and again found not guilty following the governing body's appeal.

Although Irvine hinted that he personally thought the incident may have warranted punishment, he was quick to point out that the Lions accepted Horwill's non punishment.

"It's a difficult one. Just purely personally looking at it, in my view it doesn't look very clever, the ball wasn't close to it," Irvine said.

"But I've seen a hell of a lot worse in my time and it's really up to the judicial officer, he looked at all the different angles and replays.

"(Judicial officer) Nigel Hampton is a very decent guy, he's a very experienced individual. If that's his decision then we're happy to accept it."

Although the original decision was condemned by many, Irvine says that Horwill's case is not one where a consensus would be found.

He added: "You can't slap his wrist - he's either found guilty or he's innocent. If you asked 100 people (about it), you would probably get a 50/50 or a 60/40 split.

"It's not one of those where you're going to get a 95/5 decision, it was always going to be marginal. But, as I say, it's history now, it's water under the bridge.

"There is nothing we can do about it so let's move on."

Irvine also dismissed suggestions that the Lions pushed for an appeal to be made, stating that they had moved on from the incident after the orginal decision to clear the lock.

Irvine said: "We had nothing at all to do with requesting the IRB to look at it, we were as surprised as anyone when the IRB said they were going to investigate it.

"As far as we're concerned, once the judicial officer gave his decision last week, we were of the view that it was done and dusted. It's really irrelevant as far as we're concerned."

  • Share:

Post Comment

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private

Related

Lions v Australia, third Test 2013

Warren Gatland has not closed the door on future Lions tours

Gatland open to Lions reprise

Warren Gatland has admitted he would consider leading the British and Irish Lions to New Zealand in 2017.

Vickery: Greatest modern Lions performance

Vickery: Greatest modern Lions performance

Phil Vickery thinks the British & Irish Lions series in Australia is one of the greatest modern performances he has seen.

O'Driscoll delighted with series win

O'Driscoll delighted with series win

Brian O'Driscoll is delighted to be part of a winning British and Irish Lions series team

Poll

Most Popular

Features

The Off Load

The Off Load

Rupert Cox reviews the weekend's rugby including another win for New Zealand and a loss for Toulouse.

English Rose

English Rose

The values of English rugby were underlined on Monday as they launched their new kit in association with Canterbury.

Mental edge

Mental edge

Thinus Delport, Sean Fitzpatrick, Michael Lynagh and Gonzalo Camacho react to the Rugby Championship