Rugby Championship: New Zealand v South Africa and Australia v Argentina assessed

Last Updated: 14/09/13 3:46pm

  • Share:
Du Plessis: Sent off after just 42 minutes in Auckland

Du Plessis: Sent off after just 42 minutes in Auckland

Sky Bet

Another fascinating round of Rugby Championship action unfolded on Saturday, with New Zealand conquering 14-man South Africa in Auckland before Australia edged out Argentina.

Both games were shown live on Sky Sports - and you can see the next round of fixtues on September 28 live on Sky, too.

Here's what our pundits made of the action.

New Zealand 29-15 South Africa

Read our match report

Former, NZ captain, Sean Fitzpatrick: The first 42 minutes was fantastic with the intensity of the two teams who were playing with real intent. There was huge physical presence and a great fight. I thought Beauden Barrett played really well when Dan Carter went off and the loose forward trio did really well. But you look at that first 42 minutes and there was concern - the All Black scrum was under pressure, the line out was under pressure... but for me it's a tragedy that after 42 minutes we have a player sent off who was yellow carded in the first half when he should'nt have been yellow carded.

Bismarck du Plessis was outstanding in the first half - it was a one man show. Was his first yellow a high shot? The call from the ref was no arms, which quite clearly was wrong; that yellow was wrong. The second yellow was a yellow, without question. But it was a result of the first yellow.

Former South Africa wing, Thinus Delport: On the back of the first yellow Brodie Retallick scored a well executed try and suddenly they went from 7-3 to 14-3 and immediately that put a lot of pressure on the Springboks.

It's hard not to bring in emotions here, but if you bring it back to the bottom line, South Africa weren't clinical enough when opportunities came along. The basic skills weren't there. There were too many passes by Ruan Pienaar down to the floor, Zane Kirchner was not able to deal with high balls and there was concern in terms of the defensive line. But that red card had a massive impact on the game. After 42 minutes you could feel the emotions drain and it was effectively game over. Yes, the All Blacks kept playing and the Springboks tried hard to defend, but it's difficult.

Australia 14-13 Argentina

Read our match report

Former Australia fly-half, Michael Lynagh: Critics will get off Australia's back a little, because they're now performing from a position of strength, where they've won a game. But there's still a lot to do.

It's not going to get any easier because they are going to South Africa and then Argentina after that, then come over to England. It's a long road but I was a little bit more pleased with the attitude that was shown out there. There was a great deal of intensity and the players showed it meant something to them.

It wasn't a great night for rugby but Australia applied themselves and did their job. There's a big question mark over them going to South Africa and facing that big pack but what better way to try to start turning things around - there are some tall mountains to climb, though.

Former Argentina lock, Mariano Sambucetti: Argentina can take a lot of good from this tour. They can take a lot of good from having played the All Blacks in New Zealand and there was parity, if you take away the yellow card. Today could have been for either of the two teams. Unfortunately, Australia got it. But it's step after step for Argentina and it's moving forward.

This team has to focus on rugby, playing and it will come. As hard as it is to wait for that win, it will come. The support back home will be there - any national team will always have a full crowd there supporting them.

  • Share:


The Rugby Championship 2013

James Horwill: Everything clicked into place

Horwill: Came right in the end

James Horwill was a satisfied Australian skipper after the Wallabies crushed Argentina 54-17 in Rosario

Just two good

New Zealand and South Africa have taken rugby union to a whole new level, says Will Greenwood.

Richie McCaw: Victory didn't come easily

McCaw: We had to dig deep

Richie McCaw admitted the All Blacks were pushed to the limit during their 38-27 victory over South Africa on Saturday

Most Popular


Perfect partners

Perfect partners

Sir Ian Botham praises Joe Root and Jimmy Anderson's 'tremendous' last-wicket partnership.

Extraordinary Joe

Extraordinary Joe

Joe Root’s determined resistance on day three at Trent Bridge won praise from Nasser Hussain.

Balague: Enrique can tame Luis

Balague: Enrique can tame Luis

Barcelona boss Luis Enrique will be able to control Luis Suarez, Guillem Balague told Sky Sports News.