Neil Hudgell seeking investigation into Super League refereeing standards

Last Updated: 27/05/13 11:24am

  • Share:
Chris Green scoring the controversial late try in Hull FC's derby win

Chris Green scoring the controversial late try in Hull FC's derby win

Sky Bet

Hull KR chairman Neil Hudgell wants the RFL to investigate refereeing standards in the wake of their controversial defeat at the hands of Hull FC at Magic Weekend on Saturday.

Referee Steve Ganson decided to award a contentious late try to Rovers' cross-city rivals, a decision that proved to be wrong, and Hudgell confirmed Ganson had rung him to apologise on Saturday evening.

But while recognising Ganson's upset over the decision, Hudgell feels an apology is not enough in this case and would like the game's governing body to investigate the general standard of refereeing, which he feels is lacking.

"I am a pragmatist, it's gone now. We can't get the result back. We have to take it on the chin, give credit to FC for sticking in, and respond in the right way," Hudgell said.

"I know that come the middle of the week this will all be consigned to history and we will sit and look at the table and see ourselves sitting outside the top eight. It is up to us to show resolve and not let this ruin our season.

"At the same time though, I owe it to the fans, players and coach to ask for the RFL to issue a proper explanation for what has to be the single worst decision in the last 10 years of rugby league.

"Going into the last 10 minutes we had three tough calls go against us, with a blatant knock on in the lead up to Hull's first try, a phantom offside by us giving them the position from which Kirk Yeaman scored, and a video referee decision on the grounding which was highly questionable in my opinion.

"I can't have any complaints over those in isolation, although they were wrong, in the same way we benefitted from some similar calls last year. But any one of them being called right would have avoided the last call. The amount of money and resource ploughed into the officials' department entitles us to expect better and more consistently correct decisions.


"I had a call last night off Steve Ganson with an apology and explanation for making the wrong decision. I like Steve and respect him for doing that, and our conversation will remain private. The apology since issued by the RFL though is wholly inadequate.

"I have a group of players who are distraught that their efforts have not had the reward which they deserved. I have supporters who have again turned up in their numbers at great expense and who feel cheated, and a coach fighting for a new deal whose livelihood could stand or fall on these decisions.

"For all of them I need more than 'sorry' from an ex-Hull FC player, coach and vocal advocate down the years. It is empty and tokenistic and an insult to our fans. The clear impression is that 'sorry' is enough and all is forgotten come Tuesday when everyone goes back to work. They are baffled and mystified and need to know why the call was made, and what lessons will be learnt from it.

"In my opinion, we are no further on in improving the standard of refereeing than we were at the inaugural Magic Weekend when there was the Leeds versus Bradford fiasco, and the reason for that, in no small part, is down to the 'respect campaign'.

"Legitimate criticism and debate is suppressed by a zealous desire to cover over incompetence, serious weaknesses and under performance. Every week someone, somewhere feels aggrieved, and it's us this week. I have zero confidence that will change any time soon."

  • Share:


Ganson gaffe

Steve Ganson: Major error in Hull derby

Ganson replaced as video ref

Steve Ganson has again been relieved of video referee duties for Monday's clash between Huddersfield and St Helens.

Rob Burrow: happy with the use of video technology in rugby league

Rob - RL to learn from gaffe

Rob Burrow has backed rugby league to learn from Steve Ganson's video-refereeing gaffe at the Magic Weekend.

Chris Green: Scored controversial late try for Hull

McDermott issues action call

Leeds Rhinos coach Brian McDermott wants lessons to be learnt from the video referee's mistake during the Hull derby.


Most Popular


Super League stats

Super League stats

Who has kicked the most goals this season? Which player is penalised the most? Find out here...

Good Week/Bad Week

Good Week/Bad Week

So much can change in a sporting week and, sure enough, there have been plenty of highs and lows.

One of the greats

One of the greats

Jonathan Doidge believes Challenge Cup win confirmed this Leeds team as one of the greats.