Jim Goldie's pair Forrest Flyer and Grandad Bill, who holds Royal Straight and Maid Of Meft on Musselburgh running, both have claims in this but Sennockian Storm has yet to she is effective on this surface. Silver Tigress has a bit to prove in this grade but Distant Waters could go well upped in trip and The Oil Magnate has winning form on soft ground and is lightly-raced for his age. HERRERA profited from a cool ride from apprentice Laura Barry to score at Beverley last month, however, and is only 2lb higher here. She should follow up if Paul Hanagan can get her settled over this longer trip.
Forrest Flyer (IRE) 16-1 (8-13) In touch, outpaced over 3f out, ridden over 2f out, weakened final furlong, 9th of 12, 13l behind Jonny Delta (8-10) at Musselburgh 1m 5f hcp (4) gd.
The Oil Magnate 14-1 (8-13) Chased leaders, led over 4f out, ridden 2f out, headed over 1f out, soon weakened, 7th of 11, 13l behind Hail Bold Chief (8-8) at Doncaster 1m 2f app hcp (5) gd in Aug.
Sennockian Storm (USA) 6-1 (8-12) Close up, ridden over 3f out, weakened over 1f out, 8th of 13, 10l behind Raktiman (9-3) at Wolverhampton 1m 6f hcp 0-75 (5) pol in Aug.
Grandad Bill (IRE) 7-1 (8-11) Mid-division, outpaced over 3f out, ridden and kept on same pace from over 1f out, no impression, 6th of 14, 6l behind Think Its All Over (9-6) at Musselburgh 1m 5f hcp (4) gd.
Maid Of Meft 14-1 (9-2) Held up in rear, outpaced on outside over 3f out, never dangerous, 10th of 14, 11l behind Think Its All Over (9-6) at Musselburgh 1m 5f hcp (4) gd.
Royal Straight 16-1 (9-0) Towards rear of mid-division, outpaced over 2f out, never on terms, 8th of 14, 11l behind Think Its All Over (9-6) at Musselburgh 1m 5f hcp (4) gd.
Herrera (IRE) 4-1fav (8-12) Held up in mid-division, headway and edged left over 2f out, chased clear leader over 1f out, stayed on under pressure to lead post, won at Beverley 1m 2f app hcp (6) gs in Aug beating Petomic (9-8) by ns, 9 ran.
Distant Waters 9-1 (9-4) Held up mid-division, ridden and headway over 1f out, kept on to take 2nd close home, 2nd of 13, 3/4l behind Appyjack (8-11) at Kempton 1m 2f stks 0-55 (6) pol.
Vittachi 66-1 (8-12) Held up towards rear, ridden and weakened over 2f out, 10th of 14, 15l behind Aegean Destiny (9-1) at Newcastle 1m 4f hcp 0-65 (6) sft.
Silver Tigress 13-8fav (9-3) Keen in touch, ridden over 2f out, effort over 1f out, kept on inside final furlong, never going pace of leading pair, 5th of 9, 2 1/4l behind Kian's Delight (9-1) at Catterick 1m 4f 3yo hcp 0-60 (6) gd in Aug.