Skip to content

Martin Tyler's stats: Premier League penalties and substitute goals

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Martin Tyler brings you his latest teaser from the Stadium of Light as Sunderland face Newcastle in the Tyne-Wear derby.

This week, Martin Tyler's stats and facts column looks at which players have the most successful Premier League penalty record, as well as the fixtures that have produced the most goals.

How to send your questions to Martin:

Tweet @SkyFootball using the hashtag #TylersTeasers.

Martin's Starting Stat

Sunderland enjoyed their fifth consecutive win in the Tyne-Wear derby on Sunday afternoon and they are now seven unbeaten against Newcastle, which equals their best ever run against them. The five wins in a row equals the Newcastle’s feat from February 2002 to April 2006, while September 1957 to October 1963 is the last time Sunderland went seven unbeaten against Newcastle. 

The most astonishing statistic is perhaps the second-game syndrome. Paolo Di Canio, Gus Poyet and Dick Advocaat all lost their first game in charge of Sunderland and all won their second game in charge - which was against Newcastle.

Advocaat became the fourth different Sunderland boss in the last four home games against Newcastle; Steve Bruce (August 2011); Martin O’Neill (October 2012); Gus Poyet (October 2013) and Advocaat (April 2015).

John O'Shea has now made 19 career appearances against Newcastle without defeat.

Jermain Defoe, who was playing in his first Tyne-Wear derby, scored a memorable goal. In 18 North London derbies he only scored once. It was his seventh goal in 19 appearances against Newcastle and his 127th Premier League goal, which puts him joint 11th with Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink – with more to come you would suspect.

In 140 league derbies, Sunderland have now won 46. Newcastle have won 51 and there have been 43 draws. Overall there have been 154 derbies and Sunderland are now level with Newcastle on 53 wins with 48 draws.

In the Premier League there have been 26 derbies, Sunderland have won eight, Newcastle have won nine and there have been nine draws.

On the spot

Eden Hazard struck as Chelsea won 2-1 at home to Stoke
Image: Eden Hazard scored Chelsea's 100th successful Premier League penalty against Stoke

I read that Chelsea scored their 100th Premier League penalty against Stoke. Have they scored the most penalties in Premier League history? (James, Glasgow) 

MARTIN SAYS: That's right, Eden Hazard's spot-kick on Saturday was Chelsea's 100th Premier League penalty goal, but they're not quite top of the all-time list. Jose Mourinho's side are second, but it is Liverpool who top the charts with 102 Premier League penalty goals.

Chelsea are fourth on the all-time list of penalties awarded (114), but have a remarkable scoring rate, putting away 100 of their spot-kicks. Liverpool (133), Arsenal (125) and Manchester United (117) have won more, but only Liverpool have converted more.

The Reds have put away 102 of their 133 penalties, two more than Chelsea, with Arsenal (94 goals from their 125) and Manchester United (89 goals from their 117) lagging behind. 

All-time Premier League penalties (scored and awarded)

1. Liverpool (102 goals from 133 awards)

2. Chelsea (100 goals from 114 awards)

3. Arsenal (94 goals from 125 awards)

4. Manchester United (89 goals from 117 awards)

5. Newcastle (89 goals from 111 awards)

6. Everton (79 goals from 102 awards)

7. Tottenham (71 goals from 100 awards)

8. Aston Villa (64 goals from 95 awards)

Eden perfect

Dimitar Berbatov
Image: Dimitar Berbatov has scored all nine of his Premier League penalties

Eden Hazard has scored nine out of nine Premier League penalties.Which other Premier League players have never missed? (Ben, Surrey)

MARTIN SAYS: Eden Hazard’s spot-kick against Stoke, as mentioned earlier, was memorable for the fact it was Chelsea’s 100th successful penalty in Premier League history, but on a personal level he also moved joint-top of the 100 per cent record charts.

Hazard and Dimitar Berbatov have both scored nine from nine, the highest number of penalties taken while still retaining a 100 per cent record, while Manchester City’s Yaya Toure has scored all eight of his. Liverpool legend Jan Molby only managed seven Premier League penalties in the back-end of his Anfield career, but he scored all of them.

There are eight players who have taken six penalties and scored every one: Elano, Stephen Hunt, Craig Gardner, Graham Alexander, Garry Parker, Rickie Lambert, Santi Cazorla and Clive Wilson.

Honourable mentions must go to Wilfried BonyMario Balotelli and Shola Ameobi, all still playing, who have all scored five from five, and could still make the list if they step up to take another.

It’s worth mentioning Leighton Baines, who was top of this list earlier this season after scoring 14 consecutive penalties – before David de Gea saved his 15th kick.

Super subs

Victor Anichebe pulls one back for West Brom to make it 3-1
Image: Victor Anichebe pulls one back for West Brom to make it 3-1 against Queens Park Rangers

Victor Anichebe scored another goal from the bench on Saturday. Has any player scored more times as a sub than when they started? (Malcolm, Kidderminster)

MARTIN SAYS: Victor Anichebe’s record is remarkable, and he does indeed have the highest percentage of substitute goals in Premier League history.

We asked our friends at Opta to look at those players who have scored a minimum of 20 goals in the top flight and tell us who has the highest percentage from the bench. The West Brom striker is the only man with a percentage above 50 per cent (59.1), scoring 13 of his 22 career Premier League goals as a substitute.

Second on the list is Roman Pavlyuchenko, who spent four years at Tottenham between 2008 and 2012; he scored 45 per cent of his Premier League goals off the bench (nine of 20).

Ex-Aston Villa, Swansea and West Brom man Luke Moore, who is now plying his trade with Toronto in MLS, comes in at third with 40 per cent (eight from his 20), while Szilard Nemeth, the former Middlesbrough man, is fourth with 39.1 per cent (nine from 23).

The one name you’d perhaps expect to make the list, such was his impact from the bench for Manchester United, is Javier Hernandez. He scored a memorable 37 goals in the Premier League, and 14 of them (37.8 per cent) came when he started as a substitute.

Games with most goals

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - FEBRUARY 10: Mario Balotelli of Liverpool scores during the Barclays Premier League match between Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur at A
Image: Mario Balotelli scores his first Premier League goal for Liverpool against Tottenham

In the mid-nineties Liverpool v Newcastle produced classic after classic… but which Premier League fixture has produced the most goals in history? (Geraint, Cornwall)

MARTIN SAYS: You’re right, I can remember some fantastic battles between Liverpool and Newcastle in the past, but it is not the fixture with the most goals in Premier League history.

That title goes to Liverpool v Tottenham, a fixture that has produced a magnificent eight goals just this season. Mario Balotelli scored his first Premier League goal for Liverpool at Anfield in February, as Brendan Rodgers’ side ran out 3-2 winners, while the Reds’ 3-0 win at White Hart Lane in August was also full of goals.

That fixture has produced 134 goals since the inception of the Premier League in 1992, three more than the second-placed fixture: the north London derby between Arsenal and Tottenham (131 goals).

The aforementioned Liverpool v Newcastle battle is third on the list of fixtures with the most goals (130), alongside Chelsea v Tottenham with the same amount. However, it’s worth pointing out that Newcastle and Liverpool have met fewer times than the other fixtures mentioned (Newcastle have sent two seasons outside the Premier League).

I am often asked about the greatest game I’ve ever commentated and the 1996 version of Liverpool 4-3 Newcastle is the answer I always give. I’m looking forward to commentating on Monday night’s game for the Premier League, which can be heard if you’re not viewing in the UK.

Not Roo again!

Wayne Rooney of Manchester United celebrates
Image: Wayne Rooney of Manchester United celebrates after scoring against Aston Villa

Wayne Rooney netted his 13th goal against Aston Villa at the weekend, more than he’s scored against any other side. But which Premier League player has scored the most goals against one team? (John, Stockport)

MARTIN SAYS: Alan Shearer is far and away the Premier League’s all-time top goalscorer, so it is perhaps unsurprising that has scored the most goals against one team.

The Newcastle United legend scored a remarkable 20 goals against Leeds United in the Premier League era.

Shearer also scored 16 against Everton – a tally matched by Les Ferdinand, who also scored 16 against Everton in his career.

Shearer has also scored 14 against Southampton, Coventry and Tottenham.

Rooney’s 13th goal against Aston Villa puts him next on the list of most goals against one opponent, alongside Frank Lampard (13 against Aston Villa), Michael Owen (13 against West Ham and Newcastle) and that man Shearer again (13 against Sheffield Wednesday).

Watch the Manchester derby, Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool on NOW TV with a Sky Sports Week Pass.

Around Sky