Select a Team

Barclays Premier League

Old Trafford (ATT 75,233) 7th December 2013 - Kick off 12:45

Man Utd Manchester United vs Newcastle United Newcastle


Newcastle 1

Y Cabaye (61)

Desperate Moyes?

Another rotten day for David Moyes, whose desperation for a win was epitomised by the selection of an unfit Robin van Persie in attack. It is looking pretty worrying indeed, writes Daniel Storey...

By Daniel Storey - @danielstorey85.   Last Updated: 08/12/13 1:21pm

  • Share:
Manchester United have suffered back-to-back defeats at Old Trafford in the Premier League

Manchester United have suffered back-to-back defeats at Old Trafford in the Premier League

After an absolutely woeful midweek for David Moyes, a rotten weekend follows. Two home defeats in four days, and no goals scored in the process, if Manchester United's manager was under pressure before the match against Newcastle United, the serious questions over Moyes' long-term future will now be asked louder and more vehemently. This looks a truly mid-table side.

RVP going nowhere

Manchester United manager David Moyes has rejected claims that Robin van Persie has asked to leave Old Trafford. Click here.

Given the club's current slump, it was clear before the game that even the smallest opportunity to gain a lift would be taken by the manager, and the returning fitness of Robin van Persie was seen as the chink of light at the end of a particularly dark tunnel.

Moyes had admitted on Thursday that he had no idea when the Dutchman would return from a niggling injury but his words certainly did not hint at a comeback two days later. Moyes had said: "I do not know [when he will return]. We have been trying to get him back for a few weeks. But he is not ready yet. It is his groin."

Even before the kick-off against Newcastle, Moyes seemed unsure. "I am not sure whether he can give me 90 minutes," he admitted. As it happened, the situation demanded that he did play the full match.

Is David Moyes the right man for Manchester United? Some fans have their doubts

As Newcastle manager Alan Pardew remarked, it was no real surprise to see Van Persie rushed back. The absence of Wayne Rooney (suspension), Shinji Kagawa (illness) and Marouane Fellaini (left out the squad completely, quite the statement) left a hole that only Van Persie could fill. His name was widely cheered around Old Trafford when the PA announcer read it out.

It is easy to understand why Moyes took even the smallest opportunity to start his Dutch striker. Despite whisperings from some that Van Persie's absence actually helped Manchester United to perform, the statistics highlight just how crucial he is to United's success. Of the nine Premier League games he has started this season before Saturday, Moyes' side had won six and drawn two. A 66 per cent win ratio is not as good as United managed last season but it would have been enough to win the title.

Without Van Persie, United's record is abysmal in the league. They have started five games without their top scorer from last season and taken just two points. Matches against Manchester City, West Bromwich Albion and Everton have been lost (two at home), with points also dropped at Cardiff City and Tottenham Hotspur. It is clearly a small sample but spread that record across a whole season and United end up on 15 points, the second lowest in Premier League history. Wayne Rooney's form, it seems, can only take you so far.

Unfortunately, it became almost instantly evident that Van Persie was far from fit, despite Moyes' assertions. During an uninspiring first half from the home side, Van Persie had just 18 touches, almost half of which were the taking of set pieces. He was involved in nine duels and won just two. More worrying still, he failed to have a single shot, and whilst Javier Hernandez and Adnan Januzaj buzzed around busily, their team-mate looked laboured in possession.

Van Persie played only one meaningful long pass (l), did not have a shot and had just 18 touches (r)

Towards the start of the second half, we finally saw a glimpse from Van Persie. Dropping into his own half to pick up the ball, he sprayed a 60-yard pass to Hernandez, who forced Tim Krul into a diving save. It was the exception that proved the rule - these are the passages of play that we have come to expect from a man with such talent. Even when the ball was provided on a platter and Van Persie nodded home, the offside flag denied him an equaliser. It was the striker's only effort on goal of the match, and that just about epitomised it completely.

In truth, the selection screamed of a manager starved of options and rather short on ideas. Left without the currently effervescent Rooney, Moyes chose the only option he felt confident in.

That fact says very little about Moyes' confidence in Fellaini, too. Whilst the Belgian has struggled considerably in a withdrawn midfield role this season, it is easy to forget that the summer signing from Everton's preferred position is either in an advanced midfield role or just off a forward man. Moyes must know this, having selected him there on numerous occasions last season. With that in mind, it would have been preferable to start with Fellaini off Hernandez, with two of Nani, Antonio Valencia and Januzaj to provide crosses to both forwards. It may have been less pretty but United could not have been less effective.

Van Persie is a fantastic forward, of that there is no doubt. But selecting a player clearly unfit (and at least lacking match fitness) from the start demonstrates perfectly the pressure Moyes is currently feeling at United.

This was the roll of the dice, the cross-fingers-and-hope-for-the-best approach. Old Trafford has not grown accustomed to such strategies, and six months before the end of the season is a worrying time to be resorting to such measures. Especially when they fail to work so evidently.

Moyes' view

"There will be [light at the end of the tunnel], because it is a transitional period and that was always going to be the case.I hoped it would not have been as poor as it has been in the last few games. When I came here I knew it was never going to be easy and it has proved to be that way."

Pardew's view

"Sometimes when you get victories of this manner, it is difficult to digest straight away and obviously the headlines might be elsewhere. But I hope the players get credit for their performance. I could still hear our fans singing when I was down the tunnel. It is a huge win for them."

A version of this article first appeared on Football365

  • Share:

Latest Poll



Barclays Premier League

Barclays Premier League
Pos Team P Pts
1 Chelsea 4 12
2 Aston Villa 4 10
3 Swansea City 4 9
4 Southampton 4 7
5 Manchester City 4 7
6 Tottenham Hotspur 4 7
7 Arsenal 4 6
8 Liverpool 4 6
9 Manchester United 4 5
10 Hull City 4 5
11 Everton 4 5
12 Leicester City 4 5
13 West Ham United 4 4
14 Stoke City 4 4
15 Sunderland 4 3
16 Queens Park Rangers 4 3
17 Crystal Palace 4 2
18 Burnley 4 2
19 West Bromwich Albion 4 2
20 Newcastle United 4 2


Man Utd v Newcastle

Manchester United: need to take more big risks, says Neville

The fury's out

Gary Neville says Man Utd's title dreams are probably over after failing to play with enough "fury" this season.

David Moyes: Manchester United boss takes responsibility for poor form

Moyes takes the blame

David Moyes says he takes "complete responsibility" for Manchester United's poor results in the Premier League.

David Moyes: Saw Manchester United lose to Newcastle on Saturday

Moyes: United fans patient

David Moyes believes Manchester United fans appreciate the bigger picture facing the club at the present time.