Select a Team

Barclays Premier League

Britannia Stadium (ATT 27,101) 15th September 2012 - Kick off 15:00 Ref: M Clattenburg

Stoke Stoke City vs Manchester City Man City

Stoke 1

P Crouch (15)


Man City 1

J Garcia (35)

Potters hold the champions

Controversial Crouch goal hands Stoke a point

By Matt Briggs.   Last Updated: 17/09/12 5:51pm

  • Share:

Stoke thwarted champions Manchester City at The Britannia Stadium for the fourth season in a row as they earned a controversial 1-1 draw on Saturday afternoon.

Man of the match: Man City debutant Javi Garcia was a towering influence. He scored one powerful header and almost grabbed a late winner with another thunderous headed effort, but for a world-class stop by Asmir Begovic. But his all round game was also impressive as he managed to help City dominate the midfield against Stoke's scrappers. He will be a great addition to City's talented squad. Save of the match: Begovic made a sublime late stop to deny Garcia from a corner. The former Benfica man climbed majestically to head goalwards but Begovic, somehow, kept it out with a very strong hand! Talking point: Referee Mark Clattenburg's decision to allow Peter Crouch's first-half opener. It was blatantly handball as he wriggled free in the area and as Roberto Mancini pointed out afterwards: "It's football, not basketball!" Stat of the match: Today's 1-1 draw was the fourth time in succession this fixture has ended with that scoreline.

The corresponding fixture in the previous three seasons had ended 1-1 and goals from Peter Crouch and Javi Garcia, on his debut, made it the same scoreline once again.

Crouch fired Stoke ahead with just 15 minutes on the clock with a close-range finish, but the beanpole striker appeared to use his hand in the build-up. Crouch chested down a high ball into the box from Jonathan Walters and then used his hand to knock the ball past a couple of defenders before slotting home.

City levelled on 35 minutes though when Garcia drifted into the box unmarked and expertly headed Carlos Tevez's left-wing free-kick past the stranded Asmir Begovic.

Stoke improved after the break and enjoyed more possession, but it was still City who created the best second-half chances.

The impressive Yaya Toure saw a 12-yard shot brilliantly saved by Begovic and then the big keeper somehow got a hand to Garcia's thumping header and tipped it on to the post before gathering at the second attempt.

City still pushed forward and substitute Edin Dzeko thought he had won it with the last kick of the game after he lobbed the ball over Begovic, but Ryan Shawcross was on hand to clear the ball off the line.

Stoke had thrown on former England striker Michael Owen for his debut in the last minute but his introduction came too late for him to make an impression.

Garcia had been one of three debutants in the visitors' side along with Maicon and Scott Sinclair, while Steven Nzonzi made his Stoke bow and Charlie Adam his first start.

The champions made a positive start as Sinclair broke into the box to whip in a low ball but Robert Huth cleared.

Carlos Tevez also fought off the attention of Nzonzi to get away a shot from long distance but it was deflected narrowly wide.

Stoke went ahead in contentious circumstances after 15 minutes when Crouch, with his back to goal, benefited from a touch with the hand as he controlled a Jon Walters cross and turned Joleon Lescott.

He then enjoyed another slice of luck as the ball took a ricochet off Garcia but he still showed nimble footwork to tuck the ball away.

It was far from the spectacular volley which lit up last season's fixture between the two sides but, with no offences spotted, he gleefully accepted it all the same.

City looked for a response and Tevez played in Mario Balotelli with a superb through-ball.

Balotelli, cleared to play after successful eye surgery during the international break, had looked in the mood and dealt well with Stoke's attempts to rile him throughout.

He wrong-footed the defence with a smart turn but clipped a well-struck left-foot effort over the bar.

Yaya Toure whipped a long-range free-kick just over after Balotelli had received some rough treatment - not for the first or last time - from Andy Wilkinson.

City's equaliser came from another free-kick, which Stoke surprisingly failed to cope with, after 35 minutes.

Garcia was allowed a free header as he ran in to make firm contact with Tevez's curling cross. The closest Stoke player to him, Adam, appeared to have been impeded by his own team-mate Marc Wilson.

The visitors almost went ahead moments later as Maicon forced Begovic to tip around the post with a powerful low volley.

Stoke made a positive start to the second half and Garcia, signed on deadline day from Benfica for a reported £18million, was tested defensively.

He mistimed one tackle on Nzonzi, made another fine effort to win the ball from Walters but was then booked for a crude challenge on Michael Kightly.

Crouch thought about recreating his stunner from six months ago as he flicked up the ball outside the box and attempted to volley but he miscued horribly and Joleon Lescott cleared.

Kightly, coming into the game after a quiet first half, also got forward but saw his shot blocked by Maicon.

Toure, so often City's talisman, attempted to spark his side into life and charged forward to play a fine-looking ball through for Sinclair.

Sinclair failed to reach it as Shawcross stretched out a foot but the ball rebounded for Toure, who continued his run and brought a superb save out of Begovic.

The game was interrupted when Balotelli went down after an apparent off-the-ball clash with Wilkinson, the pair having shadowed each other most of the afternoon.

Referee Mark Clattenburg spoke to the players but took no action and replays did not suggest anything serious had occurred.

Balotelli, however, maybe feeling wronged, snatched at a shot moments later and failed to work Begovic.

Owen received a huge ovation when he warmed up but manager Tony Pulis resisted the temptation to use him until the last minute.

City pressed for a late winner and Samir Nasri turned in the area and went down under pressure but nothing was given. The Frenchman then stung the palms of Begovic with an 18-yard effort moments later.

In a frantic finish, Garcia was denied brilliantly by Begovic and Shawcross did just as well to prevent Dzeko snatching victory.

Stoke CityTeam StatisticsManchester City
11st Half Goals1
2Shots on Target8
1Shots off Target3
1Blocked Shots4
0Yellow Cards1
0Red Cards0
69.3Passing Success84.3
86.4Tackles Success90
49.1Territorial Advantage50.9
287Total Passes585
20Total Crosses18
166Lost Balls156
28.81st Half Poss.71.2
37.22nd Half Poss.62.8

  • Share:



Barclays Premier League

Barclays Premier League
Pos Team P Pts
1 Chelsea 38 87
2 Manchester City 38 79
3 Arsenal 38 75
4 Manchester United 38 70
5 Tottenham Hotspur 38 64
6 Liverpool 38 62
7 Southampton 38 60
8 Swansea City 38 56
9 Stoke City 38 54
10 Crystal Palace 38 48
11 Everton 38 47
12 West Ham United 38 47
13 West Bromwich Albion 38 44
14 Leicester City 38 41
15 Newcastle United 38 39
16 Sunderland 38 38
17 Aston Villa 38 38
18 Hull City 38 35
19 Burnley 38 33
20 Queens Park Rangers 38 30