Live Commentary
Last Updated at 9:58 pm, April 30th 2012
-
A huge cheer rings out around the Etihad Stadium as the final whistle goes, with City winning 1-0 to return to the top of the Premier League on goal difference.
-
90+3
Roberto Mancini makes his final change of the night to bring on James Milner for Samir Nasri.
-
83
United make their third and final change, with Ashley Young replacing the ineffective Nani.
-
82
Micah Richards is brought on in place of David Silva to further shore things up for Man City in the closing stages.
-
79
Michael Carrick fouls Gareth Barry right next to the managers' dugout and is shown a yellow card. Sir Alex Ferguson is not interested in speaking to Roberto Mancini on this occasion.
-
78
It was something of a surprise that Antonio Valencia did not start but he is on now, replacing surprise Paul Scholes for the closing stages.
-
76
Nigel de Jong goes in clumsily on Danny Welbeck and is shown a yellow card, but the real action comes on the touchline as Sir Alex Ferguson and Roberto Mancini almost square up to each other, only to be kept apart by officials.
-
70
Phil Jones becomes the first United player to be cautioned following a wild challenge on Gareth Barry in midfield.
-
68
Carlos Tevez will not score against his former club tonight as he is replaced by midfield enforcer Nigel de Jong. Quite a surprising decision to withdraw Tevez, but De Jong will add steel to the City midfield.
-
58
Sir Alex Ferguson decides it is time to make his first change and brings on Danny Welbeck for Park Ji-sung to give Wayne Rooney some more support up front.
-
53
Yaya Toure is booked for dissent after disagreeing with Andre Marriner's decision to give United a free-kick for a foul on Ryan Giggs.
-
The half-time whistle goes and City walk off to a standing ovation. They have dominated this match without creating too many chances, but Kompany struck at a crucial time just before the interval and the onus is now on United to respond.
-
45+1
GOAL David Silva delivers the corner and Vincent Kompany climbs highest to beat Chris Smalling in the air and power a header past David de Gea. The crowd erupts and that goal is fully deserved for City.
-
19
Referee Andre Marriner plays the advantage following a foul on Wayne Rooney by Vincent Kompany in midfield but Ryan Giggs' cross is intercepted by Joleon Lescott. Marriner returns to the scene of the crime to show Kompany a yellow card.
-
19.45
Manchester City are at 11/10 with Sky Bet and Manchester United are 12/5, with a draw 5/2. You can get odds of 11/1 that David Silva will be the first goalscorer, while Wayne Rooney is at 6/1.
-
19.35
"Hey, I'm Ayus Praharaj from Bhubaneswar, India. I'm going for a convincing 1-3 win for Manchester United with Rooney scoring a brace, and Nani also getting on the scoresheet! Go Uniteeedddddd!!!"
-
19.33
Angus in Edinburgh, aged nine, writes: "Well its gonna be a late night but good action. I'm in my City pjs so I think it will have 3 reds and 5 yellows. Wazza with a hat-trick and Tevy with 2 and that to be the final score. Come on the City."
-
19.28
"Hi it's Josh, I am a united fan and i think that people have got to be realistic in what they say. I believe it will be a very different defensive performance by both teams and one goal will decide it. I think that with United's current run of high goalscoring matches that United will barely come on top early in the second half with Paul Scholes to score from range. 1-0 to United."
-
19.25
Scot in Ft Lauderdale: "Sir Alex has certainly loaded his team with experience. The only familiar name missing from this line up is Captain Mainwaring!"
-
19.22
"Hi, David a Walsall fan from Walsall. Would love to see Manchester City to win tonight and throw the title chase straight to the wire, would love a new name on the trophy, always liked City ever since they were promoted with The Saddlers back in 1998/99 - Weird to see them challenging for the title while Walsall are battling against relegation to League 2. I predict 1-0 to City with a Carlos Tevez winner in the last 5 minutes."
-
19.20
Chris Dunkerley says: "That United team is a disgrace. How can they possibly compete. They do not deserve to win this match let alone the league. City to win 3-1."
-
19.15
Jim in Taiwan says: "Late night but hope it's going to be worth it.I'm a Leeds fan so obviously hoping for a City win. I predict 4 red cards..loads of gum chewing."
-
19.02
Harry says: "So excited yet anxious about this game can't wait for kick-off. As a United fan I want United to win I think the final score will be 4-1 to United! Come on you Reds title N0.20 is on the way!"
-
19.00
Qasid in Bromley writes: "I'm a Man Utd fan and I know that this will be an incredibly close match with both teams trying to go for the win. Aguero and Tevez to score in the first half before Utd produce a fight-back with Rooney to score before 60 mins and let's say Hernandez to level the scoreline in stoppage time. Oh and De Gea to make a penalty save somewhere along the way."
-
18.55
"Hi, I'm Harry from Newbury, this is going to be one hell of a game, I think Fergie has the edge here, but this all depends on his selection, Man city have been riding their luck all season and certainly have a fear factor against most clubs in the Premiership, but these kind of games really do suit Utd and they will overcome I'm sure, City still need a point to prove and both sides have a defence that is leakable, with goalscorers wanting to stamp their mark, so goals to be had tonight so I'm going with 3-2 maybe 4-2 utd, there will be goals there usually is......."
-
18.52
John Bagust in Prague says: "United will not lose tonight.They have the experience to handle City at this moment in the title race. 0-1 to Utd with a goal from Rooney. Shame tomorrow is a day off here in Prague - would love to see some of my City colleagues after we win!"
-
18.45
Arthur Albiston writes: "I feel Sir Alex has a lot more options than Mancini - you could probably pick most of the City lineup but Fergie will keep you guessing. I would be happy with a point but have a feeling United will break City hearts (or Hart) with a late winner - 2-1 United."
-
18.42
Spurs fan Stu says: "Evening Lewis, hoping for an exciting game for the neutral tonight..! I'm going for 3-2 to Utd, Rooney to get at least 2. And 3-2 at 28/1 not a bad shout"
-
18.40
Gabriel Sutton is the first to get in touch, saying: "Dead excited about tonight's game, even as a neutral Birmingham city fan! Gutted I'm out playing table tennis tonight but hopefully I can catch the highlights later on. Whilst I can't wait for the game, I think the winner will definitely win the title, there could be an element of nerves and anti-climax about it. I could see a 0-0 draw." Tough choice Gabriel, a night of table tennis or the Manchester derby.
Matches
-
Barclays Premier League
Table
Barclays Premier League
| Pos | Team | P | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Manchester United | 38 | 89 |
| 2 | Manchester City | 38 | 78 |
| 3 | Chelsea | 38 | 75 |
| 4 | Arsenal | 38 | 73 |
| 5 | Tottenham Hotspur | 38 | 72 |
| 6 | Everton | 38 | 63 |
| 7 | Liverpool | 38 | 61 |
| 8 | West Bromwich Albion | 38 | 49 |
| 9 | Swansea City | 38 | 46 |
| 10 | West Ham United | 38 | 46 |
| 11 | Norwich City | 38 | 44 |
| 12 | Fulham | 38 | 43 |
| 13 | Stoke City | 38 | 42 |
| 14 | Southampton | 38 | 41 |
| 15 | Aston Villa | 38 | 41 |
| 16 | Newcastle United | 38 | 41 |
| 17 | Sunderland | 38 | 39 |
| 18 | Wigan Athletic | 38 | 36 |
| 19 | Reading | 38 | 28 |
| 20 | Queens Park Rangers | 38 | 25 |







