Select a Team

Barclays Premier League

Etihad Stadium (ATT 40,072) 19th April 2009 - Kick off 15:00 Ref: M Jones

Man City Manchester City vs West Bromwich Albion W Brom


W Brom 2

Live Commentary

Last Updated at 4:57 pm, April 19th 2009

  1. And the final whistle goes to bring surely the best Premier League match of the weekend to an end. Thank you for tuning into today's commentary and don't forget to follow all the reaction next. Cheers.

  2. 90+4

    GOAL STURRIDGE! City finally put the game to bed with Ireland teeing up the sub to kill off the game with an easy finish.

  3. 90+3

    Meite, who is playing as a striker now, is given offside.

  4. 90+2

    West Brom throw everyone forward leaving Petrov and Sturridge to finish the game of but neither finds the finish.

  5. 90

    West Brom play it short and Brunt cracks one from distance and Given beats it away.

  6. 89

    City will have to play with ten men as Zabaleta trundles off, West Brom come forward they look to find an opening and Kompany concedes a free-kick for fouling Simpson.

  7. 88

    Zabaleta is down and signals to the management team that he can't carry on.

  8. 87

    Baggies have a throw-in in City's half but they give the ball away cheaply. Brunt, then wins it back and releases Simpson who skins Zabaleta but can't find a ball into the box and it's a corner.

  9. 86

    Sturridge runs into trouble and Mulumbu comes away with the ball, he finds Robinson who pings it across goal, but the flag goes up with Fortune given offside.

  10. 85

    Kompany pokes the ball into the net but ref Mike Jones rules it out.

  11. 84

    SUB Petrov comes on and Robinho comes off for City to the approval of the Eastlands faithful

  12. 83

    Robinho strikes the free-kick into the wall.

  13. 82

    Zuiverloon has raised his game as City tire and he wins back possession for West Brom, but Zuiverloon is penalised for fouling Sturridge.

  14. 80

    Brunt picks up a loose ball after a good run from Zuiverloon, but the midfielder can't bend his shot into the top-corner.

  15. 79

    The free-kick drifts into the box, it falls to Valero but he hits his shot straight at Given.

  16. 79

    De Jong concedes another free-kick in Brunt territory.

  17. 78

    Fortune nutmegs Dunne and gets a shot off and Given puts it behind for a corner.

  18. 77

    West Brom are hustling for an equaliser but City have the ball until Robinho loses out to Robinson.

  19. 76

    West Brom deliver another dangerous set-piece into the box, but Fortune is caught on his heels and it's a goal-kick to City.

  20. 75

    SUB City's Elano comes off to a round of applause for Fernandes.

  21. 74

    YELLOW CARD Kompany goes into the book for persistent fouling.

  22. 73

    Man City have the ball and they play it left to Elano, who tries to find Robinho but West Brom defend the cross well and Carson gathers.

  23. 72

    Greening nearly ghosts his way through three City players in the box, but the Albion captain is crowded out after another good Baggies move.

  24. 71

    Brunt has the chance to put another deadly ball into the box after De Jong's latest foul. Brunt does just that and City struggle to get it clear - it falls to Simpson and he puts a great ball into the box but the flag is up with a West Brom player given offside.

  25. 70

    West Brom have a free-kick in Man City's half but they waste it as Zuiverloon fails to hunt down a long-ball.

  26. 69

    Elano goes for goal, but he puts it too far left.

  27. 68

    Zuiverloon goes to sleep and lets Robinho in, then the Baggies defender pulls the Brazilian back and concedes a free-kick in a dangerous position.

  28. 67

    SUB: Mulumbu comes on in West Brom's final sub and Morrison comes off.

  29. 66

    YELLOW CARD Morrison goes into the book for punching the ball into the ground.

  30. 65

    City have the chance to wrap up the game with Sturridge leading the counter-attack, but Elano's shot it tame and Carson has the ball.

  31. 64

    Bridge fouls Morrison and Baggies get chance to put another set-piece into City's penalty area.

  32. 63

    SUBS: Simpson and Valero come on for Dorrans and Koren

  33. 62

    Given is nervy with the resulting free-kick and he puts it behind for a corner. Olsson goes close with a header from the set-piece but it goes wide.

  34. 61

    The game is becoming so open as Olsson wins a foul from Kompany in City's half.

  35. 60

    Sturridge makes a good start and smacks a left-foot shot at goal, but Carson gratefully holds onto the ball.

  36. 59

    Sturridge gets onto the ball, he feeds Elano who sticks one to the back post, but West Brom (eventually) get it away.

  37. 57

    SUB Caicedo departs for the young Sturridge.

  38. 56

    GOAL ELANO The Brazilian makes no mistake and City have the lead again.

  39. 55

    PENALTY Elano is sent tumbling from Olsson's challenge and West Brom shoot themselves in the foot yet again.

  40. 53

    GOAL BRUNT Brunt fizzes the free-kick into the danger-zone, but no-one gets a touch and with Given committed the ball nestles in the left-corner.

  41. 52

    The tempo of the game slows down and Onuoha bundles Fortune to the ground and gifts Baggies a dangerous free-kick.

  42. 50

    City try to ease Albion's second-half dominance but Robinho can't bend his shot into the corner.

  43. 49

    Fortune is stopped from getting a close-range shot on target by Dunne's interception and West Brom have another corner.

  44. 48

    Corner is sent in by Greening and West Brom appeal for another penalty and see their shouts turned down again.

  45. 48

    West Brom win a corner after Robinho tried to play himself out of trouble in the penalty area. Albion players claim for hand ball but the ref turns it down.

  46. 47

    Brunt takes the free-kick and City clear it but only as far as Morrison and he tries to hammer one home but Given holds onto the ball well.

  47. 46

    Ireland sees City start on the front foot, Caicedo tries to blast one but it doesn't come off and Albion move forward with the ball until De Jong brings Morrison down with a cynical foul.

  48. 45

    Man City kick off the second half.

  49. The teams are back to out for the second-half.

  50. HALF-TIME 2-1 to City The ref brings a brilliant first-half to an end. Robinho netted his first goal of the year, before City doubled their lead through Onuoha albeit in dubious fashion after Caicedo appeared to have blocked off Carson. West Brom had the better of the chances and they got a deserved goal when Brunt hit home Fortune's knock. What do you think to the opening period, send your views to

  51. 45+2

    Greening skips past De Jong, but Fortune loses it and City come on the counter-attack. Caicedo has time to get a shot off, he blasts it, but it's straight at Carson and he beats it away.

  52. 45+1

    Man City still have possession, until Fortune wins it deep in his own half.

  53. 45

    Man city have a throw-in on the half-way line, they go backwards and play it simple as two minutes of added time is announced

  54. 44

    Fortune tries to bustle a shot a goal, but Dunne makes the block which sees the ball trickle into Given's arms.

  55. 43

    Handball by Zabaleta given after some wonderful one-touch football by West Brom in the middle of the park.

  56. 42

    Zuiverloon tries to wrestle Kompany and is penalised for the foul.

  57. 41

    Elano's delivery is met by Olsson. Morrison picks up the loose ball but nearly puts Carson is bags of trouble with a back pass but the goalkeeper smashes it clear.

  58. 40

    Elano makes a good run and wins a corner for Man City.

  59. 38

    City make a good response but they can't carve out a goal-scoring opportunity with Baggies pressing well.

  60. 36

    GOAL BRUNT West Brom work it down the right, Fortune picks it up and lays it off to Brunt who smashes a low left-foot shot past Given. Deserved goal for the away side.

  61. 35

    Caicedo has a tug of Ollson's shirt and is penalised. West Brom free-kick.

  62. 34

    Morrison tries his luck on the volley from close-range, but he can't direct it goalwards.

  63. 32

    Robinho wins a free-kick deep in Baggies' half and the Brazilian wins the flick-on from the resulting set-piece but it goes behind for an Albion goal-kick.

  64. 30

    Greening pumps it into the mixer, Given gets a weak fist on the ball. It loops to Koren who heads it goalwards first-time, and it looks like it could sneak in, until Caicedo heads it clear.

  65. 29

    Another good Baggies move results in a corner.

  66. 28

    Brunt has been the Baggies best player so far, but he gives the ball away in City's half.

  67. 27

    Baggies come forward but Fortune loses out to Robinho who plays in the overlapping Bridge and he puts in a terrific cross which Elano squanders miss-hitting his effort.

  68. 26

    West Brom have had the better of the chances, but are 2-0 down, story of their season!

  69. 25

    Brunt turns provider a launches a great cross from the right, pin-point onto Fortune's head but the striker lacked any conviction and it's a City goal-kick.

  70. 24

    Brunt gets a header on goal from Olsson's flick on but it's a poor effort.

  71. 22

    Ireland nearly adds a third, but Miete and Olsson manage to halt the midfielder.

  72. 21

    BOOKINGCarson is booked for is complaints about the goal

  73. 20

    GOAL CITY DOUBLE THEIR LEAD The corner comes in from Elano and Onuoha heads it in. Caicedo looked to have blocked Carson after the first header went into the skies. But the ref saw no problem and the goal stands.

  74. 19

    Brunt comes forward with the ball and pelts a cross into the box, but City clear the ball and go on the counter attack which leads to a corner.

  75. 18

    West Brom go long, but it comes straight back and Ireland wins a free-kick on the half-way line after Dorrans clattered into the midfielder.

  76. 16

    Robinho finds Caicedo in the box, but his shot is tame and it goes behind for a Baggies goal-kick.

  77. 15

    Caicedo picks up the ball 25-yard from goal and is unpressured so he turns, steadies himself and try to bend a left-foot shot in the top corner. But he misses his mark.

  78. 14

    Zuiverloon is suffering a tough time stopping Robinho, who wins a foul from the Dutchman.

  79. 13

    West Brom try to get their passing game going and play it well down the right. Zuiverloon picks up the ball on the by-line but his cross is far too deep for Fortune and City have possession.

  80. 11

    Greening fizzes it and Olsson forces a corner. The corner is initially cleared to Koren who plays a lovely reserve ball to Morrison who tees up Meite who has to score from two yards....but the Albion centre back has concrete feet and he bustles the ball the wrong side of the post.

  81. 10

    Robinson bombs down the left and wins a free-kick off Elano right near the corner flag.

  82. 9

    Robinho is flagged for offside.

  83. 8

    GOAL ROBINHO West Brom give the ball away on the half-way line and Ireland has it in the middle. He brings the ball forward gets his head up and delivers a wicked ball into the box, and Robinho drifts into the box and connects beautifully on the volley to give City the lead.

  84. 7

    Robinho and Elano are forced into a corner and the Baggies win a goal-kick.

  85. 6

    Robinho picks up the ball on the left, he jinks past Zuiverloon and tries his luck from distance. Carson dives down to his right and puts it behind for a corner.

  86. 5

    Koren wins possession in City's half, he releases Morrison and it opens for the midfielder and he bends a shot goalwards but it whistles narrowly past Given's left-post.

  87. 4

    Brunt tries to send Morrison down the right, but Brunt can't execute the pass, Man City come down the right and Elano wins a throw-in.

  88. 3

    Fortune gets another sighter at goal, but he drags his shot wide.

  89. 2

    The flag goes up for Robinho, who strayed offside.

  90. 1

    Albion start with some good possession, Brunt finds Fortune in the box but Onuoha puts the tackle in.

  91. KICK OFF West Brom get us under way.

  92. The sound of the Stone Roses blasts around Eastlands, before a U2 classic "Beautiful Day" gets me looking forward to today's game. Gareth from Wales emails in fancying Robinho to score his 1st goal since December and City to win comfortably 4-1. Gareth can get odds of 80/1 with Skybet if he fancies putting money on his prediction and so can you.

  93. What's your view on today's fixture? Send your emails into me at

  94. Meanwhile West Brom manager Tony Mowbray appears to be starting with a 4-5-1 formation with Marc-Antoine Fortune in the lone striking role.

  95. So manager Mark Hughes makes one change from the side that was knocked out of Europe in midweek with Nigel de Jong coming in for Micah Richards.

  96. The team news is in so here goes.



Barclays Premier League

Barclays Premier League
Pos Team P Pts
1 Chelsea 22 52
2 Manchester City 22 47
3 Southampton 22 42
4 Manchester United 22 40
5 Arsenal 22 39
6 Tottenham Hotspur 22 37
7 West Ham United 22 36
8 Liverpool 22 35
9 Swansea City 22 30
10 Stoke City 22 29
11 Newcastle United 22 27
12 Everton 22 23
13 Crystal Palace 22 23
14 West Bromwich Albion 22 22
15 Aston Villa 22 22
16 Sunderland 22 20
17 Burnley 22 20
18 Hull City 22 19
19 Queens Park Rangers 22 19
20 Leicester City 22 17