Conclusions from the Korean GP

Vettel and Red Bull once again have the look of champions, Schumi the Second should remember the message of Schumi the First, while Lewis should stay at McLaren if he really wants a challenge...

By Pete Gill.   Last Updated: 15/10/12 2:56pm

  • Share:

And then there were two
To play it by numbers: After three successive wins for Sebastian Vettel, and with four races remaining, there are only two drivers left in the title race and just one car to be in. The tide has well and truly turned.

The RB8 has been upgraded into a dominant force, its qualifying weakness fixed to decisive effect by the successful introduction of a Double DRS device which Lotus have abandoned after two months of futile experimentation. It's a winning combination: the inspiration of Adrian Newey and the perspiration of a team willing to work around the clock to stay out in front. That's why they are champions and why, in all likelihood, they will be again.

We should never have doubted them. But for a brief interlude at the start of the season when the team grappled with the new exhaust regulations, Red Bull have been F1's dominant force for the past three-and-a-half years. Their recent upsurge is particularly ominous because they have found a new burst of energy at a time when each of their leading rivals - McLaren with their reliability woes, Lotus and Ferrari with development failures - have wavered. The harder it gets, the longer the season goes on, the better Red Bull do. They sprint to the line when everyone else stumbles at the end of a slog.

This is a team built for a sustained period of success; what we're seeing now, with Vettel not yet at his peak and Toro Rosso operating as the breeding ground for Red Bull's next generation of champions, may only be the tip of the iceberg.

As for this season, it's already a long way back for Fernando Alonso even though his deficit to Vettel stands at an apparently-meagre six points. The Spaniard remains beyond reproach, but there is only so much he can do in a car that has fallen a second off the pace. He needs more and he's now admitting as much.

Carefully positioned in Ferrari's press briefing on Saturday was an exhortation from their de facto team leader demanding another push and new parts for India. "We must improve it and I expect to see some updates coming, right from the next race in India," proclaimed Fernando.

Alonso has morphed into the ultimate team player and it's fair to assume that Fernando wouldn't have demanded improvements unless he was confident that a shipment from Maranello will be on the plane to Delhi in two weeks' time. Likelier still, however, is the prospect of Red Bull wheeling out yet another, more powerful suite of upgrades for a car which remains in constant evolution. It's the stuff of champions - and what Red Bull do better than all the rest.

Is it too soon for Lewis to have second thoughts?
With Mercedes only faster than Caterham, HRT, Marussia and Williams this weekend, a decision that what was, at best, quirky two weeks ago, is already looking increasingly reckless - if not foolish. Lewis Hamilton, still arguably the fastest driver in the field, has seemingly committed to a team that is only avoiding going backwards because it is stuck in a rut.

Even more disconcertingly, the rationale behind his decision to leave McLaren is fast unravelling. Hamilton says he wants the challenge of trying to win in a bad car, but, as of this weekend, it's a near certainty he will leave McLaren with a single championship after four years of failing of be a sufficiently-regular winner in a good car. Meanwhile, Vettel is poised to be crowned Sebastian the Third in a team threatening to rule F1 like despot. There's an uncomfortable question begging to be asked: is Hamilton joining Mercedes for a more difficult challenge but avoiding an even harder one by leaving McLaren? At Mercedes, Hamilton could be considered to have succeeded even without winning. At McLaren, it's only win or fail.


Sky Sports F1 HD is THE only place to watch the 2012 F1 season in full live. Our extensive coverage continues with the Indian GP exclusively live on 26-28th October.
FRIDAY 26th - P1 from 5:15am. P2 from 9:15am
SATURDAY 27th - P3 from 6:15am. Q from 8:30am
SUNDAY 28th - Race from 8.00am
To find out all the different ways to watch the action, click here

The end can't come too soon for Schumi
Because the career of the most successful driver in F1 history shouldn't be ending like this - and he knows it. "It's better to bow out when you're battling for the title than to trundle around at the back of the field," Schumacher declared as he called time on the first installment of his career in 2006 and how that warning must have resonated inside Michael's Mercedes on Sunday as he duly trundled around at the back of field two seconds off the pace in a car not worthy of him, either in this incarnation or the last. Fortunate to finish 13th, Schumacher's suffering was unabated ignominy.

What should be a dignified exit has instead turned into a squalid long goodbye. For a sport which prides itself on precision and attention to detail, it is bewildering that the two biggest transfer stories of the year - Hamilton's move to Mercedes and Schumacher's return to retirement - have been so poorly handled. Schumacher reputedly had ultra-brief notice of Mercedes' plan to announce Hamilton's capture; in return, he only informed Mercedes of his retirement on the morning he convened a hastily-assembled press conference to announce his exit at Suzuka.

At McLaren the situation is cringeworthy and awkward, Hamilton's discomfort manifesting itself in a series of ill-judged but revealing tweets and sixteen reserved bowling lanes going to waste in Japan. Three weeks after it was announced he was departing the team he has driven for since boyhood, Hamilton is still yet to speak to the man who mentored his progression into F1, Ron Dennis, or explain his decision to his race engineers in face-to-face talks.

It should have been handled so much better than this.

Money talks loudly on the driver merry-go-round
Poor Kamui Kobayashi, it seems he is just too poor for F1. Paid drivers are not a new phenomenon for F1 but they seem more valuable than ever - how else to reconcile Sergio Perez being good enough for McLaren and yet Kobayashi, who has out-qualified his team-mate more often than not this season and is just behind the Mexican in the standings, not being considered good enough for Sauber in 2013?

Pole position is on the wrong side of the grid at Yeongam
And as a result, all the leading drivers starting with an odd-numbered grid slot suffered at the start of Sunday's grand prix: by the end of the first lap, every top-ten driver to have started on the right hand-side of the grid had lost position to the driver starting on his left.

Vettel was easily able to slip past Webber because he had the inside line to turn one

While Vettel's move past Webber illustrated the first flaw in the circuit's design, with Sebastian fractionally behind his team-mate until they reached the braking zone when he simply out-positioned his team-mate because he held the inside line and Webber had further to go to reach the apex, Alonso's pass on Hamilton into the second turn simply made it an absurdity. It's bad enough to put the pole-sitter on the outside line for turn one, but close to bonkers to put him on the outside for both of the first two turns.

Decent is good for Toro Rosso, but not good enough for Red Bull
Although Jean-Eric Vergne's eighth-place finish at Korea owed plenty to the luckless demise of Daniel Ricciardo with a brake problem - the Australian would have also started five places further up the grid but for a gearbox change - it's abundantly clear that the Frenchman is steadily improving into a decent F1 driver.

His race craft far exceeds his qualifying performances and, judging by his remarkably-lenient reaction to being shunted out of the Singapore GP by Michael Schumacher, Vergne also possesses the temperament to prosper. There are exceptions, but hot-headedness is not a characteristic that any leading driver tends to carry for long.

Yet the nagging doubt - namely, a lack of obvious star quality - which has been attached to both Vergne and, albeit to a lesser degree, Ricciardo, since the start of the season has been shoved to the forefront by a repeat of this summer's rumour that Vettel has signed a pre-contract agreement with Ferrari for 2014.

Any such deal is likely to be swathed in performance-related causes, with Vettel only contracted to join Ferrari if the team are close to the summit of the Constructors' Championship at a defined period during next season, and only free to leave if, in the words of Red Bull advisor Helmut Marko, the team "slip in the Drivers' or Constructors' Championships." The timing of that clause could be particularly critical given that Red Bull tend to be late developers during a season.

We'll see. But in the meantime, even the fleeting prospect of losing Vettel must be causing considerable anxiety at Red Bull, not least because his departure would almost certainly be coupled with the retirement of Mark Webber (the Aussie's contract extension only amounts to a single year). The team would thus be faced with the challenge of appointing and integrating two new drivers in a single swoop for a season set to witness the most sweeping regulation changes in half a decade.

And with all the leading drivers in the sport poised to be either under contract elsewhere - Alonso, Vettel and Hamilton - or nearing the end of their careers - Raikkonen, Button, Massa - where could they turn? The answer is by no means obvious, which is why the Toro Rosso duo could be subject to intense attention next year.

Ricciardo and, as of recent times, Vergne are doing a decent job for Toro Rosso. What Red Bull need, however, is for one of them to produce the spectacular in 2013 if they are to sleep easy for 2014.

Pete Gill

  • Share:


F1 Conclusions

Conclusions from Hungary

Why Lewis Hamilton's refusal to yield did Mercedes a favour, how Merc missed a winning strategy, and...

Conclusions from Germany

Nico disappears from view, Saturdays make Sundays hard work for Lewis, and Fernando calculates a telling point...

Conclusions from Britain

Lewis Hamilton stays on the title tightrope, Williams re-enter the big time, while Alonso & Vettel mess up the message.

Most Popular


Get Sky Sports F1

Get Sky Sports F1

Watch every grand prix, and every track session, live on Sky F1 in 2015, starting on March 15 in Australia

What's new for 2015

What's new for 2015

Double points dropped, Virtual Safety Car introduced, changes to penalties, and more.

2015 TV Times

2015 TV Times

Get your diaries to the ready, folks! Here's all the TV Times you need to know for the new 2015 F1 season.